Where a 20% Crypto APY Comes From and When It Stops Paying

By Vault Capital Team·Published on ·11 min read·Also available in Português

A 20% APY in crypto is a dashboard number that, on its own, tells you nothing: APY (annual percentage yield) is one year of return with the rewards reinvested, and the useful question is not "how much" but "who pays". This post answers where a yield four or five times the US Treasury rate can come from, with a five-answer tree, a reproducible calculation and a dated case. It does not teach you to trade and does not point to any protocol, platform or product: it helps you read the number before deciding whether it belongs in a portfolio.

In short

  • The floor is the US Treasury bill: the 3-month bill paid 4.16% a year on 19 November 2026 (FRED); tokenized versions paid 3.5% to 3.9% on 21 November 2026 (DefiLlama).
  • Emissions are the most common source: on 21 November 2026, Curve's PYUSD-crvUSD pool showed a 12.8% APY, of which 0.55% was fees and 12.2% was tokens (DefiLlama).
  • Yield compresses down to the cost of borrowing: USDe fell from US$ 14.8 billion to US$ 7.6 billion once its 5.1% dropped below the 5.4% cost of borrowing USDC on Aave (The Block, 25 November 2025).
  • In 2024, 77% of DeFi yields came from real fee revenue, according to a DefiLlama report dated 27 March 2026; the rest was incentives.
Source Who pays When it stops Warning sign
Real fees (interest, swaps) The borrower or the trader When demand falls APY far above the borrow rate
Token emissions The protocol, in new tokens When the budget runs out "Reward" larger than "base"
Leverage You, through loop interest When borrow cost beats yield APY grows with the "x"
Points Nobody, for now When the conversion disappoints Only a promise of a future token
Hidden counterparty A strategy you cannot see When it loses Nobody explains the source

The floor is the US Treasury

The 3-month US Treasury bill paid 4.16% a year on 19 November 2026, per the FRED DTB3 series (Federal Reserve Bank of St. Louis). Galaxy Research, in "The State of Onchain Yield" (9 September 2025), describes tokenized T-bill products as pass-throughs of the front end of the Treasury curve, in a 4% to 5% band in 2025; on 21 November 2026, the tokenized Treasury bill funds listed on DefiLlama paid between 3.5% and 3.9% net of fees.

Whoever holds a plain stablecoin gets none of that floor, because the interest on the reserves stays with the issuer, as Where Stablecoin Yield Comes From: Four Engines, Four Risks shows. A 20% APY sits 15 or 16 points above that, and every point above the Treasury has a price, as DefiLlama puts it.

The five-answer tree

For "where does a 20% yield come from" there are only five answers, and the dashboard rarely says which.

1. Real fees: interest from borrowers or fees from traders. The borrower pays and the depositor receives a share; or a liquidity pool charges traders, with the hidden cost described in Impermanent Loss Explained: When LP Fees Do Not Cover It. Real fees do not mean low risk: on 21 November 2026, Sky's stUSDS showed a 39.74% APY, paid by the rate SKY borrowers pay to the protocol, according to its own page, which labels the product "expert-level" and warns of exposure to bad debt if liquidations do not cover what was borrowed.

2. Token emissions. The protocol prints its own token and hands it to depositors. Spark wrote on 21 May 2026 that, in high-APY stablecoin pools, the excess above base trading fees "is almost always subsidized by token emissions". The next section does the math.

3. Leverage. Someone borrows to deposit again, several times over, and the yield is the spread multiplied by the number of loops: "A 5x loop on a 2% net spread produces roughly 10% APY," as Spark puts it with data as of mid-2026. What happens when the spread flips is in Yield Looping Explained: How Leverage Turns 10% Into a Loss.

4. Points. Part of the "APY" on many dashboards is an estimate of the value of points that may become tokens in the future. Galaxy writes that these points and rewards "are not always liquid or guaranteed".

5. A counterparty you cannot see. The yield comes from a strategy run by third parties off-chain, and you only find out what it was when it loses. The 2025 case is Stream Finance: according to CoinShares, on 7 November 2025, the protocol was promising 18%, had US$ 160 million in user funds locked and, by the estimate of an on-chain analyst cited by CoinShares, US$ 170 million of supporting assets against US$ 530 million borrowed. An external fund manager lost US$ 93 million and xUSD fell to US$ 0.26, as told in When a Yield Stablecoin Is Not a Stablecoin: xUSD and USR.

The emissions arithmetic: paid in a token everyone sells

Emissions are the easiest answer to check, because aggregators split "base" from "reward". On 21 November 2026, Curve's PYUSD-crvUSD pool, as listed by DefiLlama, showed a 12.8% APY: 0.55% came from swap fees and 12.2% from token rewards. The math, with US$ 10,000 deposited in that pool at that day's numbers:

Scenario Fees (0.55%) Token (12.2%) Total for the year
Token holds its price US$ 55 US$ 1,220 US$ 1,275 (12.75%)
Token halves US$ 55 US$ 610 US$ 665 (6.65%)
Emissions end US$ 55 US$ 0 US$ 55 (0.55%)
3-month T-bill US$ 416 none US$ 416 (4.16%)

The halving is a hypothesis, not a forecast. The point is that the displayed APY is worth the token's price on the day you read the dashboard, and everyone who deposits receives the same token to sell. Galaxy wrote on 9 September 2025 that incentives "are temporary and discretionary, and when they end, the effective APY can drop significantly".

Points: the promise that is not yet money

Points are the newest answer and the least measurable: the protocol has no token yet and credits points to depositors on the expectation of a future distribution; some dashboards convert those points into an "estimated APY" at a price nobody has traded. Two facts show the discretion involved. In May 2024, LayerZero flagged 803,093 addresses as sybils (multiple wallets run by one person) and excluded them from the distribution. And the study "Airdrops: Giving Money Away Is Harder Than It Seems" (Messias, Yaish and Livshits, arXiv, July 2025) found, across nine major airdrops, that up to 66% of the tokens were sold rapidly, often in the first transaction after the claim. The points share of an APY is worth zero until the token exists, can be cut after you have deposited and, once the token exists, gets sold by everyone who received it alongside you.

When it stops: yield compresses down to the cost of borrowing

The dated case is USDe, Ethena's synthetic dollar. On 25 November 2025, The Block recorded that USDe's total value locked had fallen from US$ 14.8 billion in October to US$ 7.6 billion: the APY was about 5.1%, below "the 5.4% cost of borrowing USDC on AAVE". The strategy, in The Block's words, was depositing staked USDe (sUSDe) as collateral, borrowing USDC, swapping back to sUSDe and repeating to an effective leverage of 10x or more.

The math of the crossing is short. With 5 loops and a 2% spread (7% yield, 5% cost), the loop earns 5 times 2%, or 10% a year. With a 5.1% yield and a 5.4% cost, the spread is minus 0.3%, and the same loop earns minus 1.5% a year, before any liquidation. That is our inference, supported by the formula Galaxy writes for this kind of position: net carry multiplied by the achieved leverage factor.

Galaxy's Q4 2025 crypto leverage report, published on 6 March 2026, closes the picture: sUSDe yield fell to 3.5% while borrowing USDC or USDT cost 3.75% to 4.15%. On 21 November 2026, Ethena's own API showed a 4.75% staking yield (data point dated 18 November 2026); Galaxy notes that in early 2024 it shot above 50%, and Ethena's documentation calls sUSDe rewards "fully discretionary". The dashboard number is a snapshot; the "who pays" question is the film.

How much of DeFi is real fees

Most of the sector's yield is not invented. In "The DeFi Yield Renaissance", dated 27 March 2026, DefiLlama writes that in 2024, 77% of DeFi yields came from real fee revenues, and that lending protocols now generate the majority of their yields from borrow rates rather than token incentives. That is a sector average, not a description of any pool, and real-fee yield generally sits near the floor: on Aave v3 on Ethereum, on 21 November 2026, USDC deposits earned 2.46% a year and borrowing cost 3.66% (Aavescan). The 23% of incentives concentrates on the dashboards where the APY stands out.

What is DeFi: uses, real risks and the rules in Brazil explains what these protocols are; Crypto staking explained: yield, risks and tax in Brazil covers the yield that comes from validating a network, a different source with a different calculation.

For the portfolio decision: the question to ask before the number

None of this requires a product or a tool. It requires one question, asked before looking at the rate: who pays this yield, and what happens when that someone stops paying?

  • Real fees: they move with demand and rarely sit far above the borrow rate in the same market; when they do, as with stUSDS's 39.74%, the reason is a risk.
  • Emissions: split base from reward and redo the table with your own amount.
  • Leverage: the number is spread times loops, and it turns negative when the spread flips.
  • Points: worth zero until a token with a price exists.
  • Nobody answers: it is the fifth source, and Stream showed that depositors learn what it was afterwards.

A high yield, on its own, is not a scam; a "guaranteed" one is, and the signs are in Crypto scams: 7 most common in Brazil and how to spot them.

After the question comes the decision the dashboard will not make for you: how much of your wealth can sit in something with a variable yield and principal at risk, and how much stays at the floor. That is an allocation decision, not a rate decision. Vault Capital, a securities advisory firm authorized by Brazil's CVM under CVM Resolution 19/2021, handles that decision within the client's plan, with crypto and fixed income in the same view; what to check first is in Is a crypto advisor worth it? Who it is for, what to check. Crypto assets carry high risk, including significant volatility and the possibility of losing the invested capital.

Frequently asked questions

What is APY in crypto?

APY (annual percentage yield) is one year of return including the reinvestment of the gains. In crypto, the dashboard number is a projection: it takes the current rate and assumes it holds for 12 months (Ethena, for example, annualizes with weekly compounding). Today's rate is not a promise for tomorrow.

Is a 20% APY in crypto possible?

It is possible and it exists, but always for one of the five reasons in this post: real fees with above-average risk, token emissions, leverage, points, or a strategy you cannot see. The number is real on the day it appears; the source decides whether it lasts.

What is the difference between APY and APR?

APR (annual percentage rate) is the simple rate for the year, without reinvesting; APY includes the effect of reinvesting the yield through the year. Dashboards use both terms loosely, so it is worth checking which calculation sits behind the number.

Why does crypto APY change so much?

Because almost none of the five sources is fixed: interest moves with demand, emissions get cut by governance, a loop's spread turns negative when borrow cost overtakes yield, and points depend on a future distribution. sUSDe paid above 50% in early 2024, 5.1% in November 2025 and 4.75% in November 2026.

Is high APY in crypto a scam?

Not by itself; Sky's 39.74% and Curve's 12.8% on 21 November 2026 are real products with identifiable sources. The scam signal is different: a "guaranteed" or fixed yield, no explanation of who pays, or a requirement to deposit with someone you do not know.

Let's talk

If you are looking at a crypto yield and want to know how much of it fits in your wealth, with which share at the floor and which share exposed to tokens, leverage or a counterparty, Vault's diagnostic is free and carries no commitment, on WhatsApp, with a human advisor. Your assets always stay in your name.

Want a strategy for your crypto wealth?

Vault Capital is a CVM-authorized securities advisory. See how the advisory works, what it costs and who it is for.

Learn about the crypto advisory