Impermanent Loss Explained: When LP Fees Do Not Cover It

By Vault Capital Team·Published on ·11 min read·Also available in Português

Impermanent loss explained in one sentence: it is the gap between what your liquidity pool position is worth and what the same tokens would be worth sitting untouched in your wallet. Whether providing liquidity is worth it comes down to one calculation almost nobody runs before depositing: the fees collected have to beat that gap. This post shows the calculation with a reproducible example, says when fees cover the loss and when they do not, and brings the only peer-reviewed study with a dollar total. It does not teach you to trade and does not point to a pool, protocol or product: the question is a portfolio decision, and the answer is conditional.

In short

  • Impermanent loss is how far a pool position falls behind simply holding the tokens. By the Uniswap v2 formula, an asset that doubles in price leaves the position 5.72% behind.
  • In the example of 1 ETH + 2,000 USDC, with ETH doubling, the position is worth US$ 5,656.9 against US$ 6,000 for holding: the pool must earn more than 8.6% of the deposit in fees just to break even.
  • Across 17 Uniswap v3 pools, with 2021 data, providers finished US$ 60.8 million behind holding: US$ 199.3 million in fees against US$ 260.1 million of impermanent loss (Loesch et al., arXiv, November 17, 2021).
  • In the eight busiest Uniswap v3 pools on Ethereum, from October 14, 2025 to October 13, 2026, US$ 41.6 million in fees ended US$ 20.4 million behind holding after gas (Bitquery, October 16, 2026).
  • A position can be up in dollars and still have lost against holding. That is the blind spot.
Asset price Loss vs. holding Position vs. holding (US$ 4,000 deposit)
1.25x 0.62% US$ 4,472 vs. US$ 4,500
1.5x 2.02% US$ 4,899 vs. US$ 5,000
2x 5.72% US$ 5,657 vs. US$ 6,000
3x 13.4% US$ 6,928 vs. US$ 8,000
5x 25.5% US$ 8,944 vs. US$ 12,000
0.5x 5.72% US$ 2,828 vs. US$ 3,000

Curve from the Uniswap v2 formula, recomputed by us on November 21, 2026. The deposit is 1 ETH at US$ 2,000 plus 2,000 USDC, before fees and gas.

What impermanent loss is

A constant-product liquidity pool (the Uniswap v2 model and that of most of its competitors) holds two assets and lets anyone swap one for the other against that inventory. When the market price rises, arbitrageurs buy the cheap asset from the pool until the internal price matches the external one; when it falls, they do the opposite. For the depositor the outcome is always the same: the pool sells the asset that goes up and buys the one that goes down, automatically, without asking.

That forced rebalancing is where the loss comes from. Uniswap's help center defines it, in an article updated August 2, 2026: "Impermanent loss (IL) is when the prices of tokens in a liquidity pool change from what they were when the liquidity was added, resulting in a loss of value for the liquidity provider". The whole decision fits in one comparison: fees collected against the size of the rebalancing. The general map of pools, lending and stablecoins is in What is DeFi: uses, real risks and the rules in Brazil.

The calculation: 1 ETH + 2,000 USDC, and ETH doubles

The Uniswap v2 documentation (undated, read November 21, 2026) publishes the formula: "impermanent_loss = 2 * sqrt(price_ratio) / (1+price_ratio) - 1". In words: twice the square root of the price change, divided by one plus the change, minus one. The table above is our recomputation of the curve published on the same page ("a 1.25x price change results in a 0.6% loss relative to HODL").

Now with money. You deposit 1 ETH, priced at US$ 2,000, and 2,000 USDC: US$ 4,000, half in each asset, as the pool requires. The product of the two inventories, which the pool keeps constant, is 2,000. ETH doubles to US$ 4,000, arbitrageurs buy ETH from the pool until the internal price gets there, and your share becomes the square root of (2,000 ÷ 4,000) = 0.70711 ETH and the square root of (2,000 × 4,000) = 2,828.43 USDC.

  • Position in the pool: 0.70711 × 4,000 + 2,828.43 = US$ 5,656.9.
  • Same tokens sitting in the wallet: 1 × 4,000 + 2,000 = US$ 6,000.
  • Gap: US$ 343.1, or 5.72% of the holding value.

The position is up 41% in dollars and still finished US$ 343.1 behind doing nothing, because the pool sold 0.29 ETH on the way up. To break even, fees over the period must exceed US$ 343.1, 8.6% of the original deposit. The curve is symmetrical: if ETH halves, the gap is the same 5.72% (US$ 2,828 against US$ 3,000), on top of a drawdown. Correlated pairs rebalance little; that is why the Uniswap v2 whitepaper (March 2020) writes that two dollar stablecoins "would generally be subject to less impermanent loss".

When fees cover it and when they do not

Fees are the position's only income, and they depend on volume, not price. Three variables decide the outcome.

Volume against TVL. A pool with heavy swap traffic and little deposited capital shares out more fee per dollar; a deep, quiet pool pays almost nothing. The number to look at is daily volume relative to value locked, not the dashboard APR.

Price that round-trips against price that trends. If ETH oscillates and ends the month where it started, the gap against holding is zero and the fees are net gain. If it moves in one direction, the gap grows with the distance travelled, along the curve in the table.

Concentrated ranges in v3 and v4. The depositor picks a price interval, and the capital only works inside it. Uniswap's developer documentation (undated, read November 21, 2026) is direct: "When the price exits a position's interval, the position's liquidity is no longer active and no longer earns fees". Outside the interval the position turns entirely into the asset that fell, and Uniswap's help center, in the article of August 2, 2026, sums it up: "In most cases, concentrated liquidity in a price range will increase the chance of impermanent loss happening".

The study in dollars: US$ 60.8 million behind holding

The number most guides leave out comes from Loesch, Hindman, Richardson and Welch, "Impermanent Loss in Uniswap v3", posted on arXiv on November 17, 2021. The authors added up 17 Uniswap v3 pools, 43% of the protocol's value locked at the time, with 2021 data: fees of US$ 199.3 million, impermanent loss of US$ 260.1 million, a net result about US$ 60.8 million below what the same tokens would have returned sitting still. It is the most recent peer-reviewed figure with a dollar total; the data ends in 2021 and covers Ethereum only.

Two newer studies, not peer reviewed, point the same way. Bitquery published on October 16, 2026 an on-chain study of the eight busiest Uniswap v3 pools on Ethereum, from October 14, 2025 to October 13, 2026: providers "collected $41.6M in trading fees" and, after gas, "finished $20.4M behind what they would have had by holding the same tokens". Every ETH pool finished behind (in the largest, USDT/WETH, only 37% of the 33,840 positions beat the idle wallet); among the large ones only USDC/USDT, a stablecoin pair, finished ahead, US$ 221 thousand above holding. On the Base network, Urusov et al. (arXiv, April 23, 2026) studied WETH/dollar pools across four protocols: "only about one out of six LPs avoids losses in the selected market segment". For Solana AMMs we found, as of November 21, 2026, no study with dollar totals.

"I am up in dollars and still lost": the blind spot

The ETH-doubling example shows a position that went from US$ 4,000 to US$ 5,656.9, and any dashboard will paint that green. The mistake is comparing with the deposit. The right comparison is with the alternative you had for free: leaving the tokens in the wallet. Against that, the position lost US$ 343.1 before fees. If fees over the period added up to US$ 200, the dashboard shows a US$ 1,856.9 gain and, in the honest count, you finished US$ 143.1 behind doing nothing, and paid gas and tax on top.

What to check before depositing

Nothing below is an instruction to trade; it is what has to be in the calculation before a decision exists.

  1. Volume against TVL, with history. How much fee per deposited dollar the pool paid in recent months, not the projected APR. How a fee becomes the dashboard number, and when it misleads, is in Where a 20% Crypto APY Comes From and When It Stops Paying.
  2. Correlation of the pair. Two assets that move together rebalance little; a volatile asset against a stablecoin rebalances constantly.
  3. Range, if liquidity is concentrated. Which interval, what happens when the price leaves it and who repositions, at what cost.
  4. Gas in and out. Paid at both ends and on every repositioning; the cost is in Gas fees: what they are, why they change and tax.
  5. The swap on the way. Entering usually means swapping half the capital into the other asset, and exiting means the reverse; what each swap loses is in Slippage and Sandwich Attacks: What Your Swap Really Lost.
  6. Tax. For Brazilian residents, every crypto-to-crypto swap on the way in and out is a barter event, covered in Does Swapping Crypto Trigger Tax in Brazil? USDT, Swaps.

Is providing liquidity worth it?

It depends, and the dependence can be quantified. A pool pays off when the accumulated fees exceed the gap against holding, plus gas, slippage and tax; it does not when the asset trends, when volume falls relative to deposited capital or when a concentrated range sits outside the price. Before "is it worth it" comes an earlier question: how much of your wealth should sit in a volatile asset at all, in any form. Whoever has that share defined knows the most that can go into a pool and how much it can lose against holding without unsettling the rest. The method is in How Much Bitcoin Should Be in a Portfolio? A Sizing Method.

Deciding whether part of a crypto portfolio goes into a pool, with which pair and with what limit on the gap against holding, is an allocation decision, not a protocol decision. Vault Capital, a securities advisory firm authorized by Brazil's CVM under CVM Resolution 19/2021, handles it within the client's plan, with crypto and fixed income in the same view. Crypto assets carry high risk, including significant volatility and the possibility of losing the invested capital.

Frequently asked questions

What is impermanent loss?

It is the gap between the value of a liquidity pool position and the value the same tokens would have sitting in the wallet. It appears because the pool rebalances on its own, selling the asset that rises and buying the one that falls. By the Uniswap v2 formula, an asset that doubles or halves leaves the position 5.72% behind holding, before fees.

Is impermanent loss a real loss or only on paper?

While the position is open it is a paper gap: if the price returns to the deposit level, it goes to zero. At withdrawal it becomes final, and Loesch et al. (arXiv, November 2021) measured US$ 260.1 million of it across 17 Uniswap v3 pools with 2021 data.

How do you calculate impermanent loss?

Divide the current price by the deposit price to get the change d, take twice the square root of d, divide by one plus d and subtract one. For d = 2 it comes to minus 5.72% against holding. In dollars, multiply by what the idle wallet would be worth today; in the US$ 4,000 example with ETH doubling, that is US$ 343.1.

Do stablecoin pools have impermanent loss?

They do, but a small one, because the gap depends on the change of one asset relative to the other, and two dollar stablecoins rarely drift apart. In Bitquery's October 2026 study the USDC/USDT pool was the only large one above holding. If one of the two loses its peg, the pool fills up with the one that fell.

How much do fees need to earn to compensate?

More than the gap against holding plus gas, slippage and tax, over the same window. In the US$ 4,000 example with ETH doubling, fees must exceed US$ 343.1, or 8.6% of the deposit, just to break even.

Let's talk

If part of your crypto holdings sits in, or could go into, a liquidity pool and you want to know how much makes sense to expose, with which pair and with what limit on the gap against holding, Vault's diagnostic is free and carries no commitment, on WhatsApp, with a human advisor. Your assets always stay in your name.

Want a strategy for your crypto wealth?

Vault Capital is a CVM-authorized securities advisory. See how the advisory works, what it costs and who it is for.

Learn about the crypto advisory